Gold Star - Middletown Menu & Prices

Gold Star - Middletown offers a hearty menu centered on classic American fare with a distinctive Cincinnati twist. Known for their fresh, 100% pure ground beef cheeseburgers topped with their signature Heavenly Sauce, the combos perfectly balance flavor and value. The Classic Chicken Sandwich, featuring a southern-style fried breast paired with pickles and sauce, stands out as a family favorite. Their Coneys, smothered in original or vegetarian chili with mustard, onions, and shredded cheddar, showcase authentic regional flavors in both traditional and low-carb variations. Complementing the savory selections are their handblended shakes—like the rich Vanilla, Strawberry Chocolate, and Chocolate Banana—made from 100% real ice cream and topped with whipped cream. Guests consistently praise the fresh taste, warm hospitality, and professional service, making Gold Star a dependable spot for casual, flavorful dining. Whether refueling after sports or enjoying a relaxed meal, this Middletown location delivers comforting classics with a friendly, attentive atmosphere.